Defining vs Non-Defining Relative Clauses: Commas Can Change the Group
A defining relative clause identifies which person or thing you mean. A non-defining relative clause adds information about someone or something already identified. Commas mark the added-information clause in writing. The difference can change the scope of a claim, not just its punctuation.
Decide who belongs in the group
Imagine ten guests, of whom six requested a vegetarian meal. “The guests who requested a vegetarian meal should collect it first” identifies those six. Adding commas would present all the relevant guests as having requested that meal, which changes the factual claim. The punctuation should reflect the group you mean.
A name often identifies its referent independently: “Ana, who coordinates the bookings, will open the door.” But a name can need extra identification when several people share it. The test is not simply whether the noun is a proper name; ask whether the reader already knows who is meant.
Check whether the clause supplies an object or subject
In “the camera I borrowed,” I is the clause subject and the missing relative pronoun is the object of borrowed. In “the camera that fell,” that is the subject of fell and cannot simply disappear. Non-defining clauses retain their relative word even when it is the object.
For practice, write one sentence about the employees who completed training and another about a known team whose members all completed training. Decide which group the reader can identify without the clause. Then read the sentences aloud, allowing a pause around supplementary information without using pauses as the only punctuation test.
Clear Explanation
- Use no commas around an identifying relative clause.
- Use commas around added information about an identified person or thing.
- Use who or which for a non-defining clause, not that.
Examples
The students who booked online should use the side entrance.
The students, who booked online, should use the side entrance.
The notebook that I borrowed is on the shelf.
Mira’s notebook, which I borrowed yesterday, is on the shelf.
Quick Comparison
Common Mistake
Do not add commas merely because a relative clause is long. In “The rooms that have windows are upstairs,” the clause limits the claim to a subset. “The rooms, which have windows, are upstairs” presents all the rooms in view as having windows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I leave out the relative pronoun?
In many defining clauses, yes, if it is the object: The notebook I borrowed. Do not normally omit a subject pronoun or omit the pronoun in a non-defining clause.
Is which allowed in a defining clause?
Yes in standard usage, especially in British English. Some American style guides prefer that for restrictive clauses about things. Follow the required style without treating which as universally wrong.