By vs With: Who Did It and What Tool Was Used?
In a passive sentence, by commonly names the person or thing responsible for an action. With commonly names an instrument or material used. A sign can be painted by a volunteer with a brush. Identifying the agent and the tool separately makes instructions and accounts easier to understand.
Ask three different questions about the same action
“Who cut the fabric?” can be answered “It was cut by Rosa.” “What did Rosa use?” can be answered “She cut it with fabric scissors.” “How did she cut it evenly?” may require a method: “She marked a line first and cut along it.” The three answers supply different kinds of information.
Passive sentences need not name an agent. “The door was repaired yesterday” is sufficient when the repair matters more than who did it. Add by the maintenance team when the actor matters, and with replacement hinges when the materials matter. More detail helps only if it answers the reader’s actual question.
Watch for related expressions that follow their own conventions
By train describes a mode of transport, and with a friend describes accompaniment. Neither is the agent-versus-instrument pattern. Learn phrases in complete examples rather than turning two useful rules into definitions covering every occurrence of by and with.
Practise by describing a picture frame repair. Name the repairer using by, a tool using with, and a method using by plus an -ing form. Then rewrite the first sentence in the active voice. If the person becomes the subject, you normally no longer need the agent phrase; the tool phrase can stay.
Clear Explanation
- Use by + agent to identify who or what performed the action.
- Use with + tool to identify the instrument used.
- Use by + -ing to describe a method, as in by turning the handle.
Examples
The sign was painted by a volunteer with a small brush.
The lid was opened with a screwdriver.
The roof was damaged by a falling branch.
You can open the case by pressing the release button.
Quick Comparison
Common Mistake
Do not choose by simply because an object has a role in the event. A screwdriver is usually the tool someone uses, so the lid was opened with a screwdriver. A falling branch can be the direct cause, so the roof was damaged by a branch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an agent be a thing rather than a person?
Yes. A strong wind or machine can be the cause or performer named after by. The distinction is about its role in the event, not whether it is alive.
Is by hand the same pattern as by a person?
No. By hand is an established manner expression meaning manually. It does not identify which person did the work.